Is It Time to Replace That Old Fence? Here’s How to Know

Your fence is the first defense to your home, offering privacy and security to homeowners. It adds character while defining the boundaries of your property. Keeping your fence in good shape leaves visitors, neighbors, passers-by, and potential buyers a positive impression. It communicates that your home is in good condition and well cared for over the years. While a fence lasts 15-30 years, its longevity depends on the materials used and its after-care. A meticulously maintained fence can result from a series of repairs over time. But how do we know that patching up your fence over and over is not efficient anymore, and it’s time to replace it? Let’s explore some telltale signs that it’s time to replace your fence.

4 Tell-tale Signs That It’s Time To Replace Your Fence

1. Leaning Structure

As soon as you observe that your fence starts to lean, let professionals inspect and assess your fence. A leaning fence poses a safety risk to homeowners, passers-by, neighbors, and pets. Leaning can signify a structural issue with your fence foundation or poorly installed posts. While bracing can reinforce your leaning fence, it is a temporary solution. Permanently replacing your fence is a more efficient solution for you, giving you peace of mind.

Fig. 1. A leaning fence replaced by Modern Handymen & Remodel in Brentwood, TN

2. Wood Rot

Unlike other fence materials, wood is more at risk of termite infestation and rot, weakening your home’s fence, especially as it is exposed to extreme sunlight and moisture outdoors. While treated wood can last up to 20 years with good maintenance, untreated wood can last only 5-10 years. Deterioration is faster for untreated wood, exposing it to rot. However, the rotted portion of your fence creates a hole and gap in your fence. Professionals use the 20% rule to decide if the structure is worth repairing. If the rot consumes 20% of your fence or more, it’s time to replace it with a new one rather than just patching it up. It will be more worth your time and money.

Fig. 2. Wood rot damaging a fence in Franklin, TN

3. Constant Repairs

Repairing your fence isn’t a quick and easy job for homeowners. Some issues can become recurring due to poor maintenance and old age of your fence. When you cannot keep up with the frequent repairs of a damaged fence, your property can no longer provide security and privacy to your property as it is supposed to due to gaps, holes, or broken panels. If you find yourself constantly repairing your fence, replacing it with a new one is better. Replacing your old and damaged fence can be a smart investment. Being realistic about your fence’s condition will save you money in the long run. Replacing your fence also allows you to get a fresh start on properly taking care of it to prevent recurring issues in the future.

4. Outdated Style

Consider an entire fence overhaul if your fence is old and outdated and does not match your home style. Repairing an outdated fence can be challenging, as its materials or colors may be phased out. Finding the perfect matching pieces to complete your repairs can be a problem. Evaluate your outdated fence to see if it is worth the regular upkeep. Consider upgrading it with a new material or design to match your current home style.

Materials To Consider For Your New Fence

1. Wood

Replacing an old fence with a wooden fence can be a popular option for homeowners since natural wood is the most affordable fence material. However, affordability does not necessarily guarantee durability and longevity. Wooden fences are vulnerable to weather, UV rays, moisture, and insects. To enjoy the natural beauty of your wooden fence to its full potential for several years, consider treating or staining it every two years. Treating or staining your fence can significantly extend its lifespan.

Fig. 3. New wooden fence replacement by Modern Handymen & Remodel in Franklin, TN

2. Composite

Composite materials are durable, low-maintenance solutions for creating a strong and stylish fence. They are commonly manufactured from 60% recycled hardwood fibers and 40% recycled plastics, making composite fencing an environmentally friendly option. A properly installed composite fence can withstand extreme weather conditions like high winds and last longer than 30 years with proper maintenance.

3. Aluminum

Aluminum is a popular fencing choice due to its durability, low maintenance requirements, and attractive appearance. It comes in a variety of styles. Unlike steel, aluminum is generally lightweight and rust-proof yet more affordable. Unlike other materials, it does not require painting and refinishing. Although aluminum offers less privacy as it does not conceal much of your property, it is proven to stand the test of time while requiring minimal upkeep.

4. Vinyl

Vinyl fences generally use plastic-based material made from polyvinyl chloride (PVC). They require less maintenance since PVCs don't warp, rot, or blister. Although a vinyl fence can still be exposed to mildew and mold growth, cleaning is easier with its non-porous material and smooth finishes. Unlike wood, vinyl fences do not attract pests and insects, but they can still mimic the color schemes of wood grains.

5. Concrete

Nowadays, concrete fencing can take many shapes, forms, and designs, especially with precast moldings. High-quality concrete fences can last over 50 years, making it a top choice for durability. Concrete fencing is known for its strength, tolerating high wind speeds, especially during storms. Its surface is almost water-resistant, and mold, rot, and moisture can’t penetrate the concrete. It can only be vulnerable to chips and cracks that can cause issues for the fencing once metal reinforcements are exposed. Generally, concrete fences require little to no maintenance, providing peace of mind over the years. However, the upfront cost for a concrete fence tends to be higher than that of other fences.

How Modern Handymen Makes The Replacement Seamless

Modern Handymen and Remodel is a reputable company offering top-notch fencing services in Brentwood, Franklin, and Nashville, TN. In Modern Handymen & Remodel, we recognize the significant role of fences in every home. That is why it is essential that our professional team carefully assess the condition of your existing fence so that homeowners can make informed choices before deciding to replace it. From evaluating the extent of existing damage to factoring in the age of the fence, material considerations, and the cost implications of fence repair versus replacement, Modern Handymen & Remodel guides homeowners toward an innovative and effective solution. Navigating the intricate decision-making process is seamless when you consult professionals like our team in Modern Handymen & Remodel.

In Modern Handymen & Remodel, we understand that each fence has a unique characteristic. To tailor our services to align seamlessly with your fencing needs, we offer expert recommendations that are personalized to the unique characteristics of your fence and match your home style. Whether you need fence repair or are contemplating a complete replacement, we'll work with you to create the perfect fence that fits your needs and budget. Get a quote for your new fence in Brentwood, Franklin, or Nashville, TN. Call us at 615-200-8071 and let's build your dream fence together.